this is not a review: ‘five roses’, by alice zorn

So much of how life feels lies in the phrasing,
in the way a thought starts, then turns back upon itself
until its question hangs unanswered in the breeze.”
— from ‘North Point North’, by John Koethe

When I read these lines in Koethe’s poem I immediately thought of Alice Zorn. It’s such a perfect description of how her new novel, Five Roses, is written… all rhythms and patterns, loops, questions and connections that satisfy in surprising ways while leaving us with yet another question we’re only too happy to contemplate until the loops and connections bring us to the next answer. And so on.

It’s a delightful ride.

The story is set in Montreal, in the working class neighbourhood of Pointe-Ste-Charles where Zorn has lived for close to fifteen years. (In the spirit of disclosure may I say that I have the pleasure of calling Alice Zorn a friend, which allows me to confirm that she knows well, and loves, this part of the world. And her humour is delicious.)

“The women in tight skirts standing at the corner of Wellington, leering at the traffic, weren’t waiting for the bus.”

Not only is the story set on her home turf, but this funky ‘hood is pretty much one of the characters—a neglected and, in many ways, unknown part of town. Apparently bus service didn’t even arrive until 1992. A place of historic but crumbling townhouses once home to the workers that built the Lachine Canal, Pointe-Ste-Charles has only in recent years been ‘discovered’ and is still being gentrified. But Zorn has not written about the now. Her interest is in that sliver of time between the 1970’s when the hippies were still there, to the early 2000’s, when life in these increasingly derelict houses just trundled along, when police avoided the area and “People… knew to ignore what didn’t concern them.”9781459734241

And the people are as richly drawn as the ‘character’ of place. One man “…chewed gum with his front teeth.”  In another case “A comma of shaving foam hung from one earlobe.”

In a tiny but telling scene, a woman rides her bike to a corner shop, outside of which sits an eccentric old man in a battered kitchen chair. “She said hello so he would know she knew he was there and expected him to watch her bike, which she leaned against the storefront.”

No words are exchanged yet the moment says so much about the community that exists here and the importance of knowing how to navigate it.

Of course not everyone knows the rules of navigation and part of the happy trip of reading Five Roses  is being privy to the learning process, watching the naifs and the newbies try to ‘get it’.

Fara and her husband are two such newbies. They’ve purchased their first home, thrilled with the bargain price. The catch is that a former resident hung himself in the front room. Not a detail easy for anyone to overlook but, for Fara, it serves as a constant reminder that her sister also killed herself several years before, something she has yet to come to terms with, the guilt of the survivor. “… it wasn’t ghosts that haunted people. It was memories.”

There is Maddy, who we first meet in the 70’s when, as a naïve teenager, she finds herself living with hippies in a Pointe-Ste-Charles flophouse where “…They weren’t homes but steps toward homelessness.”  The hippies ultimately leave but Maddy stays, eventually owning the house and working as a *baker at the nearby Atwater Market. It all sounds nice enough but survival, unlike so much in The Pointe, doesn’t come cheaply and she’s made some hard choices over the years.

Last, is Rose. Named for the iconic Farine Five Roses sign. A young woman raised in a cabin in the woods north of Montreal. (Who even imagines woods north of Montreal?) She comes to the city, a complete innocent, totally unfamiliar with ‘society’, hardly able to converse; her greatest comfort being time spent weaving on a loom back at the cabin (a loom she eventually moves to an empty factory she uses as a studio; squatting is big here). One of my favourite lines, a playful adaptation of Woolf: “A loom needs a room of its own.” (And there is a stunningly beautiful description of weaving that I can not now find… but will add when I do.)

The women well represent the burden of secrets and private lives that each of us carries. Meanwhile the neighbourhood, The Pointe, where it’s assumed there are secrets (what’s life without secrets?) is a mecca of mash ups and messed up lives within which a unique community is formed. Both the women and the neighbourhood share a history of harshness, yet there’s forgiveness at the same time. Whatever you call it, there’s comfort there once you accept it, and it accepts you.

The book reminds me that every kind of neighbourhood, no matter how unassuming, has its own vibe and perhaps even draws a certain kind of person to it for whatever reason. Sometimes it’s so the person can give something to that particular place, other times it’s because they need to receive something that could come from nowhere else.

I like walking around neighbourhoods, seeing how they’re laid out, where do people buy bread, how far is it to the library? I like getting a glimpse of life through the windows and wondering who lives there and who lived there before. It’s less the way a place looks that strikes me as how it feels. And this is what Alice Zorn does she takes the reader by the hand and says see this house, this street? Let me tell you the story of it. And it’s not a story you hear or even read so much as feel.

You know an author has done her job when you close the book and for a while you continue to wonder what the characters are getting up to, you miss them a little, that guy in the kitchen chair (is he still watching bikes?)…

So, yes, if there’s ever a Five Roses  walking tour, sign me up.


Not incidental that before moving to Montreal, Zorn worked at a Toronto bakery where, among other things, she learned to make creampuffs. In a  promotional postcard for the book she shares a recipe that must not be missed. (I don’t even bake and they were flawless.)


Support Indies!

Five Roses  can be ordered on-line from Blue Heron Books.

7 thoughts on “this is not a review: ‘five roses’, by alice zorn

  1. Obviously, I’m a somewhat partial reader (not quite a bystander), but I loved reading this. Thank you, Carin.

  2. i enjoyed this book very much but found the scene with Rose and Kenny quite jarring and wonder what its real purpose was. it changed my attitude towards Rose. if that scene had played out with the roles reversed, Rose would definitely have been afraid of Kenny and would have wanted to avoid him, yet she seems sad and a bit surprised at his change in attitude towards her. That part just did not ring true. Nevertheless, the book is very well written and really draws you in and you do want to know at the end how they will all continue with their lives.

    1. My take was that she was just such an innocent, almost clueless in the ways of interacting with people. I know what you’re saying about the scene and the aftermath, but I connected it to her only other experience of men, which was Armand, and how she assumed ‘that’ was what men wanted. What SHE wanted, or any kind of emotional connection on a deeper level, seemed not even to register with her, at least not yet. This is all part of what I imagine lies ahead for Rose… all these layers of discovery where relationships are concerned. I picture her as this strangely quiet, almost wild thing; a sweet unwitting eccentric whose (artistic & other) journey is just beginning. Speaking of beginnings, how did you find the ending?

  3. Thank you, Matilda, for this astute explanation which is how I would rationalize Rose acting in the way she did.

  4. Yes, i kind of get that, although it still feels harsh somehow, compared to the rest of the book. i will probably reread this novel at some point as i think there is still more to absorb and i will definitely look for more by Alice Zorn. I liked the ending and the fact that Maddy was finally wondering a bit about Rose but that we don’t know for sure how that will turn out. One character i would have liked to know more about is Yushi–seems like such an interesting person but we don’t get to know her as well–also would like to know how Rose and Yushi met & became roommates, why Yushi is so protective of Rose …

    1. It (Rose/Kenny) was definitely a ‘moment’… I felt it too.

      My favourite thing about Alice’s style is how she takes the ‘everyday’… the simple gesture we might overlook, and subtly brings our attention to it so that we see it for what it is on a deeper level, something that resonates emotionally. I often find myself nodding (or laughing) when I read her work. (Love those moments of ultra dry humour that just ‘appear’.) She’s so good at this kind of detail. You might like her short story collection, ‘Ruins & Relics’. If you read it, Jeanne, let me know. Would be fun to discuss.

      I’m with you on the ending. Nice the way it’s not all neatly tied with a bow. She’s given us plenty to imagine various possibilities. As for Yushi… yes, would love to know her more but I wonder if too distracting (from the story) to focus on her. It’s almost a curse to have a secondary character that’s interesting! (:

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s